In the present paper, we initiate a study of a concept of amenability for discrete semigroups $S$ with identity called strict inner amenability. We first study the relations between the concepts inner amenability, strict inner amenability, and amenability of $S$. We then introduce some suitable tools and properties to give several characterizations of strict inner amenability of $S$ such as Reiter's condition and F$\o$lner's condition. We also offer a characterization of strict inner amenability in terms of a fixed point property. As applications of these results to discrete groups $G$, we obtain a number of equivalent statements describing strict inner amenability of $G$.